You are here:
Realism, Conservatism, and Tiered Ecological Risk Assessment.
Citation:
Etterson, M. Realism, Conservatism, and Tiered Ecological Risk Assessment. Ecologies. MDPI, Basel, Switzerland, 3(2):131-144, (2022). https://doi.org/10.3390/ecologies3020011
Impact/Purpose:
This manuscript is intended for the risk assessment community. In particular, it articulates an often unstated principle of population level ecological risk assessment, which is that risk assessments should gradually relax conservative assumptions with tier escalation in a tiered risk assessment. The manuscript will help risk assessors decide how to deploy ecological models for regulatory risk assessment.
Description:
Recent research has provided valuable momentum for the development and use of population models for ecological risk assessment (ERA). In general, ERA proceeds along a tiered strategy, with conservative assumptions deployed at lower tiers that are relaxed at higher tiers with ever more realistic models. As the tier increases, so do the levels of time and effort required by the assessor. When faced with many stressors, species, and habitats, risk assessors need to find efficiencies. Conservative lower-tier approaches are well established, but higher-tier models often prioritize accuracy, and conservative approaches are relatively unexplored at higher tiers. A principle of efficiency for ecological modeling for population-level ecological risk assessment is articulated and evaluated against a conceptual model and an existing set of avian models for chemical risk assessment. Here, four published avian models are reviewed in increasing order of realism (risk quotient → Markov chain nest productivity model → endogenous lifecycle model → spatially explicit population model). Models are compared in a pairwise fashion according to increasing realism and evaluated as to whether conservatism increases or decreases with each step. The principle of efficiency is shown to be a challenging ideal, though some cause for optimism is identified. Strategies are suggested for studying efficiency in tiered ecological model deployment.
URLs/Downloads:
DOI: Realism, Conservatism, and Tiered Ecological Risk Assessment.
https://www.mdpi.com/2673-4133/3/2/11#